Debunking Common Houseplant Myths — What Really Helps Your Plants

House plants are more popular than ever, but not every tip you find online is accurate. Some advice can be misleading — or even harmful — to your plants. In this article, we will debunk common house plant myths and explain what really matters for healthy growth.

 

Soil and Fertilizer Myths

Charcoal and Worm Castings Aren’t Miracle Fixes

Some sources suggest that adding charcoal or worm castings will magically improve indoor soil or make plants healthier instantly. While they can contribute to small benefits — charcoal can help with minor odor control and aeration, and worm castings provide a tiny nutrient boost — they cannot replace proper care. Healthy roots depend on good drainage, consistent watering, and balanced fertilization, not any single “magic” additive.

 

Organic Media or Fertilizer Isn’t Automatically Better

There’s a common belief that organic potting mixes or fertilizers are superior to synthetic or soilless blends. In reality, what matters most is that the soil drains well and the plant receives consistent nutrients. High-quality synthetic fertilizers or inert soilless mixes often deliver more reliable results than organic-only options.

Popular Home Remedies Are Mostly Ineffective

Eggshells, coffee grounds, banana tea, cinnamon, and Epsom salts are often touted as helpful. While they usually won’t harm your plant, they rarely provide meaningful nutrition or disease protection in indoor conditions. These DIY solutions can be fun experiments, but don’t rely on them as your primary plant care strategy.

 

Repotting and Root Myths

 

Bigger or Smaller Pots Don’t Cause Root Rot

Some say using a “too big” pot will drown roots, or that plants need tight spaces to thrive. Root rot is caused by overwatering and poor drainage, not pot size. Most plants benefit from room to grow, provided the soil drains well.

 

Repotting Doesn’t Prevent Rot

Repotting is often suggested as a way to stop root rot before it happens. While fresh soil can help if roots are already struggling, simply moving a plant to a new pot doesn’t protect it from overwatering or stagnant conditions.

 

Light Myths

Proximity to a Window Isn’t Enough

A common misconception is that simply placing a plant near a window guarantees it’s getting enough light. In reality, not all windows provide the same light intensity, and factors like window direction, time of year, and nearby obstructions (walls, trees, blinds) all matter.

How to Identify “Bright, Indirect Light”

Bright, indirect light means the plant receives plenty of natural light without being in direct sun, which can scorch leaves. Here’s how to determine it:

  1. Observe The Shadows:
  • If the shadow of a finger or object is well-defined, light is strong — often too strong for delicate tropicals 
  • If the shadow is soft or faint, it’s bright indirect light.

2. Use a Light Meter:

  • These devices measure light intensity in foot-candles (fc) or lux.
  • Measure the spot where you plan to place your plant — for most aroids and tropical houseplants, aim for 1,000-2,000 foot-candles (~10,000-20,000 lux).

3. Look at Leaf Response:

  • If leaves are yellowing, curling, or showing burn spots, the light may be too strong.
  • Slow growth or stretched stems (“leggy” growth) can indicate insufficient light.

Finding a Sweet Spot

  1. Start near a bright window (east - or south - facing if possible) but shield from direct sunlight with a sheer curtain.
  2. Rotate your plant periodically to ensure all sides receive light.
  3. Adjust gradually: Move the plant closer or farther a from the window and observe leaf health over 1-2 weeks.
  4. Watch for Subtle Changes: Healthy leaves, consistent growth, and no scorching indicate you’ve found the “sweet spot.”

By understanding your plant’s light needs and adjusting placement carefully, you can prevent stress, encourage strong growth, and avoid relying on vague rules like “any plant within 3 feet of a sunny window is fine.”


Humidity and Environmental Myths

Bathrooms, Misting, and Pebble Trays Have Limited Impact

While it’s often suggested that bathrooms, misting, or pebble trays can raise humidity, the effect is usually minimal. True humidity control generally requires a humidifier or a naturally enclosed space. You can also group plants closely together to increase humidity. A cost-effective solution if you’re unable to have a greenhouse or humidifier— clear totes (with clear lids) are a game-changer. 

Fungus, Pests, and Soil Additives

Mushrooms Don’t Always Mean Healthy Soil

Finding mushrooms in potted soil can look encouraging, but they are simply decomposing organic matter. They don’t indicate perfect soil health, and most fungi don’t provide benefits to houseplants.

 

Cinnamon and Diatomaceous Earth Are Not Cure-Alls

Many plant care guides suggest sprinkling cinnamon on soil to prevent fungus or using diatomaceous earth (DE) to control pests. While these remedies are widely shared online, they rarely provide meaningful results for indoor plants.

  • Cinnamon: While it has natural anti-fungal properties in lab conditions, in a potted indoor plant, it doesn’t penetrate the soil enough to stop root or stem rot. Applying it on top of soil mostly affects surface mold temporarily, but it cannot replace proper watering, drainage, and soil management, which are the real factors controlling fungal issues.
  • Diatomaceous Earth (DE): DE can work against soft-bodied insects like slugs or mites outdoors, but in a soilless indoor mix, it loses effectiveness. Moisture quickly deactivates its abrasive action, and insects that live inside the soil or on leaves are not impacted. Over-relying on DE can give a false sense of security, while the real solution is monitoring pests, keeping leaves clean, and using targeted, safe insecticidal treatments when needed.

 

Silica Supplements Don’t Benefit Most Indoor Plants

Silica (Si) is sometimes marketed as a miracle additive for indoor plants — promoting stronger stems, healthier variegation, or improved growth. However, most indoor houseplants cannot absorb or use silica effectively:

  • Many tropical species lack the necessary proteins (LSil and LSi2) to take in silica from the soil and move it to the leaves.
  • Any silica absorbed passively is negligible and doesn’t meaningfully strengthen stems or enhance variegation.
  • Adding silica is unlikely to harm your plant, but it won’t solve structural or aesthetic issues — proper light, watering, and nutrients are far more important.

 

Conclusion:

Not every houseplant tip you see online is reliable. Instead of following trendy hacks, focus on what truly matters:

  • Using a well-draining soil suited to your plant 
  • Provide adequate light (intensity, spectrum, duration)
  • Watering correctly and consistently
  • Using balanced fertilizers that provide necessary nutrients (Foliage-Pro is our favorite!)

Understanding the science behind plant care will save your plants stress and promote long-term growth — and help you avoid myths that don’t hold up.

Back to blog